1Initial Structure100%BReal Estate withcost of $50,000 andFMV of $200,000N CorpShareholdersN CorpVarious Assets2Contribution78% ofN CorpStockRealEstateBN CorpShareholdersN Corp3Ending Point78%22%Taxablegain of$150,000BN CorpShareholdersN CorpReal Estate and various assets(basis in the real estate is $200,000)LegendOwnership / structural holdingTransfer of stock / cash / assets

78% Control Failure Explained

B owns certain real estate which cost him $50,000 in 1930, but which has a fair market value of $200,000 in 1955.

He transfers the property to the N Corporation in 1955 for 78 percent of each class of stock of the corporation, having a fair market value of $200,000. The remaining 22 percent of the stock had been issued by the corporation in 1940 to other persons for cash.

Because B is not in control of the corporation immediately after the exchange, section 351 does not apply. B realized a taxable gain of $150,000 on this transaction.

Key Takeaways

Control means at least 80 percent

Section 368(c) control requires owning at least 80 percent of the corporation’s stock immediately after the exchange.

Pre-existing stock counts

The 22 percent of stock issued earlier for cash is outstanding and held by others, so B controls only 78 percent.

Falls short of the threshold

Because 78 percent is less than 80 percent, the control requirement is not satisfied and section 351 does not apply.

Gain becomes taxable

B recognizes a taxable gain of $150,000, the difference between the property’s $50,000 basis and its $200,000 fair market value.