A foreign business that enters the U.S. market makes its most important tax decisions before its first U.S. sale. The structure it selects determines three things. First, it determines which income is taxed on a net basis at 21% (IRC §882(a)). Second, it determines which payments are taxed on a gross basis at 30% (IRC §§881(a), 1442). Third, it determines which returns the business must file. Mistakes are costly to correct after the first year. A late return can forfeit deductions, and an undisclosed treaty position can result in penalties.
Lincoln PLLC’s international tax practice advises foreign companies on entity selection, effectively connected income analysis, treaty-based return positions, and withholding on fixed or determinable annual or periodical (FDAP) income. We work with clients nationwide and internationally. The sections below explain how each issue arises when a foreign business establishes U.S. operations.
Entity Selection for a Foreign Company’s U.S. Operations
A foreign business generally either operates in the United States directly through a foreign entity or forms a U.S. corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Each choice is taxed differently.
A foreign corporation that operates directly in the United States and is engaged in a U.S. trade or business files Form 1120-F. It pays tax at 21% on its effectively connected taxable income (IRC §882(a)). It may also owe a 30% branch profits tax on its dividend equivalent amount (IRC §884(a)), which a treaty may reduce.
A U.S. subsidiary corporation pays tax at 21% on its own income (IRC §11(b)). Its dividends to the foreign parent then bear a second level of tax through 30% withholding, which a treaty may reduce.
A U.S. LLC requires a classification decision under Treas. Reg. §301.7701-3. By default, a single-member LLC owned by a foreign company is disregarded as an entity separate from its owner. The foreign owner is therefore treated as the payee of the LLC’s income and as directly engaged in the LLC’s U.S. business. The LLC is nonetheless treated as a corporation for one reporting purpose. It must file Form 5472, with a pro forma Form 1120, for any year in which it has a reportable transaction with its foreign owner, including a capital contribution or a distribution (Treas. Reg. §301.7701-2(c)(2)(vi)).
By default, an LLC with two or more members is taxed as a partnership. A partnership must withhold under IRC §1446 on effectively connected taxable income allocable to its foreign partners. The tax sections of the operating agreement should therefore address how the members fund that withholding.
Effectively Connected Income Analysis
A foreign person is generally taxed on a net basis only on income that is effectively connected with a U.S. trade or business. Certain income is also treated as effectively connected, such as gain on U.S. real property under IRC §897. The analysis starts with IRC §864(b), which only partly defines a U.S. trade or business. That section expressly includes the performance of personal services in the United States. Case law supplies the general standard, under which U.S. activities that are considerable, continuous, and regular constitute a U.S. trade or business.
Which U.S.-Source and Foreign-Source Income Is Effectively Connected
These rules apply to a foreign person that is engaged in a U.S. trade or business during the year. For U.S.-source fixed or determinable income and capital gains, the asset-use and business-activities tests of IRC §864(c)(2) decide whether the income is effectively connected. All other U.S.-source income is treated as effectively connected (IRC §864(c)(3)). Foreign-source income is generally not effectively connected. However, IRC §864(c)(4) treats certain categories of foreign-source income as effectively connected when they are attributable to a U.S. office or other fixed place of business.
Treaty Threshold and Filing Deadlines
Without a treaty, the lower U.S. trade or business threshold generally determines whether a foreign corporation is subject to U.S. tax on its effectively connected income. A treaty raises that threshold to a permanent establishment. Even so, a foreign corporation that relies on the treaty generally must still file Form 1120-F and disclose its treaty position on Form 8833.
Filing on time also matters. A foreign corporation may lose its deductions if it does not file a timely return, which generally means filing within 18 months after the return’s due date (IRC §882(c)(2); Treas. Reg. §1.882-4(a)(3)). A foreign corporation may take the position that it has no U.S. trade or business, or no permanent establishment. That corporation can still preserve its deductions by filing a protective Form 1120-F (Treas. Reg. §1.882-4(a)(3)(vi)).
Income Tax Treaty Positions for Foreign Companies
Benefits under an income tax treaty depend on two conditions. The foreign company must be a resident of the treaty country, and it must satisfy any limitation on benefits article in the treaty. A foreign company that qualifies may reduce the 30% withholding rate on dividends, interest, and royalties. It may also avoid U.S. tax on business profits that are not attributable to a permanent establishment.
Treaty Network and Fiscally Transparent Entities
The 2016 U.S. Model Income Tax Convention is Treasury’s most recent negotiating baseline. Each bilateral treaty, however, controls its own terms. The treaty network also changes over time. For example, the U.S. treaty with Hungary ceased to have effect beginning January 1, 2024.
Fiscally transparent entities require separate analysis. When income is paid through a partnership or similar entity, an owner generally may claim treaty benefits on its share only if its home country treats the entity as fiscally transparent (Treas. Reg. §1.894-1(d)(1)).
Form 8833 Disclosure
A treaty-based return position generally must be disclosed on Form 8833 (IRC §6114; Treas. Reg. §301.6114-1). Certain positions are exempt from disclosure. One example is a claim for a reduced treaty withholding rate on dividends, interest, or royalties made on Form W-8BEN-E (Treas. Reg. §301.6114-1(c)(1)). The penalty for each failure to disclose is $10,000 for a C corporation and $1,000 for other taxpayers (IRC §6712).
FDAP Withholding on Payments to Foreign Owners
U.S.-source FDAP income paid to a foreign person is subject to 30% withholding (IRC §§1441, 1442). The withholding agent applies that rate to the gross amount of the payment, without deductions. Before payment, the foreign recipient documents its status on Form W-8BEN-E or Form W-8ECI. Common payments include the following.
- Dividends: Dividends from a U.S. subsidiary bear 30% withholding. A treaty claim on Form W-8BEN-E may reduce that rate.
- Interest: U.S.-source interest paid to a foreign person is generally subject to 30% withholding (IRC §§871(a)(1)(A), 881(a)(1)). The portfolio interest exemption removes that tax for interest on obligations in registered form when the lender documents its foreign status (IRC §§871(h), 881(c)). Interest on U.S. bank deposits is separately exempt (IRC §§871(i)(2)(A), 881(d)). The portfolio interest exemption does not apply to three types of interest. The first is interest paid to a 10% shareholder, meaning a person that owns 10% or more of the payer’s voting power or, for a partnership payer, 10% or more of its capital or profits (IRC §§871(h)(3)(B), 881(c)(3)(B)). The second is interest a bank receives on a loan made in the ordinary course of its business (IRC §881(c)(3)(A)). The third is most contingent interest (IRC §§871(h)(4), 881(c)(4)). Interest that does not qualify for an exemption, such as interest on a loan from a foreign parent to its U.S. subsidiary, bears 30% withholding unless a treaty reduces the rate.
- Royalties and rent: Withholding applies to the gross amount, without deductions. A foreign corporation may, however, elect to treat income from U.S. real property, including rents, as effectively connected and pay tax on a net basis (IRC §882(d)).
- Effectively connected income: A payment of effectively connected income is exempt from chapter 3 withholding when the recipient provides Form W-8ECI (Treas. Reg. §1.1441-4(a)). The foreign person instead reports the income on a U.S. return.
A withholding agent is liable for any tax that it fails to withhold (IRC §1461; IRS Publication 515). In addition, chapter 4 (FATCA) withholding at 30% may apply instead of chapter 3 withholding when the recipient does not establish its chapter 4 status.
Contact Lincoln PLLC for Inbound U.S. Tax Planning in North Carolina
Entity selection, effectively connected income, treaty positions, and withholding documentation interact. For that reason, these decisions should be reviewed together before U.S. operations begin.
Erik Lincoln, founding member of Lincoln PLLC, is an attorney and CPA. He brings his experience as a former senior tax manager at Ernst & Young and a former equity partner at Moore & Van Allen to inbound structuring for foreign companies.
From our Charlotte and Raleigh, North Carolina offices, we advise foreign companies nationwide on entering the U.S. market. To have a proposed U.S. structure reviewed before formation, contact our firm.